Tribunal dismisses £2bn Sony PlayStation compensation claim
The Competition Appeal Tribunal has rejected a claim that Sony restricted competition and overcharged millions of UK gamers for digital games and add-ons.
A £2 billion collective legal claim against Sony on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation customers has been dismissed by the Competition Appeal Tribunal.
In its judgment published on 17 November 2026, the Tribunal found that the claim had not established that Sony broke competition law. This means no compensation has been awarded, although the decision could still be appealed. The ruling follows a 10-week trial earlier this year.
The claim alleged that Sony used technical and contractual restrictions to prevent competing digital stores from selling games and add-on content to PlayStation users. It argued that this lack of competition allowed Sony to charge excessive prices and that gamers could have paid around 20% less if rival stores had been allowed to compete. Sony denied the allegations.
The claim was led by consumer campaigner Alex Neill, who is also a co-founder of Consumer Voice. Responding to the judgment, she said:
“We are disappointed by the Tribunal’s judgment. This case has been five years in the making and raised important questions on behalf of 12 million UK consumers. We argued that PlayStation users were being overcharged for digital games and add-on content because they were effectively locked into Sony’s digital ecosystem.
“The Tribunal has taken a different view, finding that consumers had the option of buying physical games and could anticipate their spending on games and additional content over the lifetime of a console when deciding which console to purchase.”
The Tribunal has scheduled a further hearing in the week beginning 14 December 2026 to consider any application for permission to appeal and costs.
Want to know if you could be owed money? Stay up to date on the latest consumer claims, compensation news and practical advice from Consumer Voice.

Why the Tribunal dismissed the Sony PlayStation claim
The Tribunal considered competition across the wider gaming market, rather than looking only at the PlayStation Store. It found that physical copies of games and other gaming platforms provided alternatives for consumers that could constrain Sony’s prices.
It also considered how Sony makes money from both consoles and games. Sony sells consoles at relatively low margins and recovers costs through subsequent game sales. Taking these factors into account, the Tribunal concluded that Sony’s dominance had not been established.
The Tribunal also found that the claim had not proved that allowing competing digital stores would have reduced prices by around 20%. It was not satisfied that Sony’s typical 30% margin on digital game sales was excessive or unfair.
What the Sony PlayStation judgment means for gamers
No compensation has been awarded to the approximately 12.2 million consumers covered by the claim. Affected gamers do not need to take any action. However, the legal proceedings may not be over.
Alex Neill, who led the claim, said: “We believe these were important issues to test on behalf of consumers and we are now carefully considering the judgment and our options, including whether to appeal this first-instance decision.”
The Tribunal has scheduled a further hearing in the week beginning 14 December 2026 to consider costs and any applications for permission to appeal.
Sign up to Consumer Voice for useful updates on your rights, your money and ways to get back what you’re owed.




